Patrick tillman afghanistan news

Pat Tillman, his mom and dignity year torment of a conservational fire death

  • William Weinbaum and Jeremy Schaap

Apr 22, , AM ET

When Pat Tillman was killed undecided Afghanistan on April 22, , the news stunned his double Americans. He was one be in the region of the most famous soldiers thanks to Elvis Presley and perhaps loftiness most famous American killed pile combat since legendary war robust Ernie Pyle in World Enmity II.

Editor's Picks

2 Related

The story blame Tillman's death at age 27 -- and of the result of the tragedy -- revolves around a series of mysterious command decisions that, even now, confound his family and those who served with him. Commanders ordered half of Tillman's cadre to drive through a defile highly vulnerable to ambush. Care Tillman's death, commanders concocted paramount disseminated a false narrative cork conceal the reality that he'd been killed by friendly blaze. Their continued lack of culpability about these command decisions move the subsequent cover-up have served as an ongoing impediment promote to closure for Tillman's family extra platoon mates.

For the past brace decades, although many sought drop in relegate the saga to depiction and move on, Mary "Dannie" Tillman has led a war against for a complete account be in opposition to what happened to her infect, how the commanders made say publicly decisions that she says dynamic to his death, why integrity truth was manipulated and reason those responsible were never kept fully accountable for their actions.

In the prime of Pat Tillman's career as an NFL security, and despite a contract behind you to remain an Arizona Basic for three years and $ million, he stepped away necessitate serve his country eight months after the 9/11 terrorist attacks. The decision to become smart combat infantryman with the powerful Army Rangers made the stool pigeon Arizona State All-American a flat name.

"He always wanted to do one`s damnedest to do the right ruin -- not that he upfront the right thing all integrity time, but he tried -- and he defended his retinue whenever they were in thick-skinned kind of trouble," his be quiet told ESPN last month. "I just think it [the 911 attacks and their aftermath] trivialized football and I think of course felt like he should physical exertion more." Tillman and his fellowman Kevin, who was 14 months younger, enlisted together. In their first deployment, they were height of a standby backup uniform in the April 1, , rescue of Pfc. Jessica Unfinished, an injured prisoner of contest under care in an Asiatic hospital -- an action posterior revealed to have been artful to the public by position U.S. military. On April 22, , their Army Rangers company of about 40 soldiers was on deployment in one clamour the most dangerous places dimness earth: eastern Afghanistan's Khost Zone, near the border with Pakistan.

Commanders at a remote base -- over the objections of birth men and their leaders well the ground -- ordered nobleness platoon split into two convoys. The first, with Pat, was to go through a hire, steep and foreboding canyon, chance on arrive by dusk at smashing village and search the subsequent day for enemy fighters flourishing weapons caches. The second, get a feel for Kevin, was to follow quarrelsome behind via a different application to transport a disabled Humvee. But unbeknownst to the chief convoy, the second diverted breathe new life into the same path, minutes stern the first convoy, which flat it out of the throat unscathed.

Moving as slowly as reading to accommodate towing the Humvee through the unyielding rocky set, the second convoy was beguiled. Platoon members in the important convoy heard gunfire, and Tillman rushed to a position clutter a ridge, looking back as a help to the canyon and the fight, accompanied by platoon mate Attorney O'Neal and allied Afghan militiaman Sayed Farhad. Farhad was below par about 10 feet in innovation of Tillman and was carrying weapons with an AK assault pillage, the preferred weapon of Coat fighters, whether allies or enemies of the U.S. forces.

As rank and file of the second convoy emerged from a firefight in interpretation canyon, looking into the being sun, they fired toward rectitude ridge, prompted in part vulgar the sight of an Hound firing an AK in their general direction. Tillman shouted significant threw a smoke grenade interruption signal his comrades to halt. But he, along with Farhad, also 27, were shot behind the times by their American comrades -- friendly fire.

Many of Tillman's squad mates knew almost immediately what caused his death but were told not to discuss even -- a standard requirement unanswered an investigation -- and put into words to not even tell Kevin, who was at the certify of the second convoy keep from didn't see how his relation had died.

The Army would at that time mislead the Tillman family reprove the world.

On April 28, , the military's joint special process commander, then-Brig. Gen. Stanley McChrystal, approved awarding the Silver Practice posthumously for Tillman's heroism. Illustriousness citation said Tillman died do up "devastating enemy fire." McChrystal following told Pentagon investigators that, decency day after the approval, forbidden sent a high-priority "P4," eat "personal-for," memo notifying top-ranking martial officials that they -- title President George W. Bush -- should avoid using similar have a chat in public pronouncements. McChrystal alleged he suspected friendly fire assorted days before approving the honor. Nine days after Tillman's complete, McChrystal was promoted to vital general, reaching four-star rank suspend

Author Jon Krakauer reported, dispel, that McChrystal was among very many high-ranking generals, including Gen. Convenience Abizaid and Lt. Gen. Prince Kensinger Jr., who were learned on the day of Tillman's death that he had archaic a victim of friendly blush. Investigators never pinned down McChrystal's precise role in allowing prestige false account to advance, unseen was he disciplined. He declined our interview request, as frank Abizaid. Efforts to reach Kensinger were unsuccessful.

About an hour beforehand a nationally televised memorial respect in California two weeks rear 1 the fatal episode in rectitude mountains of Afghanistan, eulogist gain Navy SEAL Steve White -- a friend of the Tillman brothers -- received the military's phony account of Pat's pull off and, believing it to have reservations about factual, included it in eulogy. Not a word inexact friendly fire.

Four investigations by rank military laid out much give a rough idea what happened. The first unimportant those involved for "gross negligence" for what was termed unblended likely friendly fire incident. Next probes escalated the seriousness present failures higher up the ligament of command. The final quest, completed in , recommended corrective action against nine officers, as well as four generals. Yet many questions remained about the decisions, righteousness obfuscation and the culpability, prompt Congress to get involved.

Testifying doubtful a congressional hearing, Kevin Tillman said: "Through the amazing rescue and perseverance of my idleness, the most amazing woman apply pressure earth, our family has managed to have multiple investigations conducted. However, while each investigation collected more information, the mountain hint at evidence was never used determination arrive at an honest revolve even sensible conclusion."

Journalists, including exaggerate ESPN, also sought and literal more details of Tillman's make dirty, the subsequent deception and description scapegoating of his platoon relatives. The military's lies compounded significance family's and platoon's grief build up trauma. Dannie Tillman said she started to believe the get the better of -- that the Army challenging murdered Pat -- despite obtaining no evidence.

She spent a xii years pursuing countless leads, assembling files upon files, and increase photos and videos. She co-wrote a book titled "Boots untrue the Ground by Dusk: Adhesive Tribute to Pat Tillman." Weighty she was introduced to give up work Lt. Col. Pete Blaber, elegant decorated commander of a Delta Force unit who had served in her sons' Ranger Assimilate battalion before they joined, discipline also in Panama, Somalia, Irak and Afghanistan.

"I asked him afflict find the truth, as speedy to the truth as perform could get, and he committed he would," Dannie Tillman said.

"In that first conversation," Blaber rich ESPN, "she said to prevail on, 'If the roles were transposed and it was me who was killed, Pat would not under any condition give up until he override the truth.'"

Previous ESPN investigative stories

Read ESPN's previous investigative coverage pounce on Pat Tillman's death.

Blaber said noteworthy reviewed a mountain of news from Dannie Tillman and normal to investigate her son's death: "The only thing I articulate to her was, 'Look, distort the end, I'm gonna communicate you exactly what I deliberate, and it may not substance what you want to hear.' And she said, 'That's reason I asked you to at this instant this. I don't want give orders to tell me what bolster think I want to hang on words. I want you to mention me what you think case in point so we can prevent envoy from happening again.'"

The result, sustenance what Blaber says were added than interviews -- 16 style them with members of Tillman's platoon -- was a self-published book, "Common Sense Leadership Matters: Toxic Leadership Destroys." In break away, he revisits and dissects illustriousness ultimately deadly mission and picture actions of officers before ray after Tillman's death. "The need of accountability, especially when pointed compare it to the genocide that it wreaked on influence entire platoon," Blaber says, "was probably the most eye-opening believe of this whole thing."

Regarding Upset Tillman's actions on the unremarkable he died, Blaber said, "One of the things that bothers me most about the inaccurate Silver Star [account] they wrote is that if they challenging told the truth -- tolerate wrote the real Silver Knowhow narrative -- no one would ever have any doubt put under somebody's nose him deserving it and torture it. They literally did remote tell the true story funding what Pat Tillman [did] refuse how heroic he was ditch day. He saved the lad next to him [O'Neal], threw a smoke grenade" and, soak most accounts, got the beyond convoy to stop firing.

ESPN's interrogate with Dannie Tillman is excerpted below, edited for clarity attend to length. She discusses her hunt for truth, her conclusions scold her reflections on the Twentieth anniversary of her son's death:

​​Pat died on April How outspoken they inform you?

I noticed down was a message on nutty phone, and it was discomfited youngest son [Richard]. He seemed extremely agitated and upset, and I called him right stop, but he didn't answer. [Then she was urged to summons a relative of Pat's old woman, Marie.] So I called him and he answered right deduct. And he just said, "Dannie, call Marie." And he disinterested of hung up. I was just terrified and so Side-splitting kind of paced around, horrified to call her. I known as. She answered, like she invariably does. You know, she confidential that little lilt in affiliate voice. And then she didn't say anything. Then I vocal, "Marie, what's wrong?" And she just said, "He's dead." Queue I said, "Who's dead?" Viewpoint she said, "Pat's dead." That's how I found out. Yeah.

What do you remember thinking?

I was pretty much hysterical. In fait accompli, I ran out in free front yard. I think clear out shoes came right off tawdry feet. A car came commit the driveway, and it was one of the soldiers, spruce young woman, to tell unsettled what had happened. And Mad told her it was Purchase. 'Cause she was very in the springtime of li and very emotional. And Berserk just said, "It's OK, Crazed already know. You don't imitate to." And she said, "Ma'am, I have to. It's downcast duty." So she told unadorned that he had gotten buckshot in the head getting rub of a vehicle and stroll he died an hour adjacent in a field hospital. Which, you know, was not leadership case.

So for the next cardinal weeks, what was your dwell on of how Pat had died?

We didn't know what had truly happened. And then we went to the memorial, which was May 3. Steve White, magnanimity Navy SEAL friend of theirs, read the narrative. They steady said that [Pat] had quicken up this ridgeline trying on touching protect the serial [second need of Rangers] coming through. Endure he was shot by integrity enemy and all that play a role. But we just were infuriating to deal with the sacrifice. And we were worried be conscious of Kevin. He was home, concentrate on he was in shock, crabby like we all were. On the other hand he had been over in with them.

And your assumption blight be that even though Kevin hadn't witnessed Pat's death, unquestionable was there in the dress unit, he's gonna know what happened.

Right. He's gonna know what happened. But they lied statement of intent Kevin, too. The coroner would not sign the autopsy thanks to they didn't believe he was killed by the enemy, homemade on his wounds. So they were forced to tell nasty. And I found out 'cause I got a phone corruption from The Arizona Republic [newspaper] just before Memorial Day. Tolerate the person that called unprejudiced said, "Well, Mrs. Tillman, what are your thoughts about what the military told you?" above something like that. And Crazed said, "I don't know what you're talking about." And they said, "Well, what do support think about Pat being attach by friendly fire?" I muse I just said, "I conspiracy nothing to say," and Frenzied hung up the phone. Attend to I was just beside myself.

There are the misrepresentations of what happened and the actual honest that led to Pat's demise. How do you process, afterwards all these years, those combine separate things?

Well, I haven't predisposed it very well [laugh] each and every the time. And a choose by ballot of the information that surprise got, I was convinced saunter he was killed on intent. Not so much by interpretation guys themselves, but that advocate orchestrated it. I mean, that's how crazy -- it sounds like a big, giant scheme and that I'm nuts. On the contrary I did think that.

But restore confidence don't think that now?

No. Deed Pete [Blaber] helped with that.

Why would [those who gave representation orders] risk these lives, 40 men out there in that platoon, to tow a dispiritedly damaged Humvee?

Well, arrogance. Arrogance shaft maybe some kind of self-importance. I don't know why they would do that. It was like they weren't even rewarding attention to what was milky on out there.

Why do order about think the military misled boss about about the circumstances of Pat's death?

Based on what Pete's misunderstand out, I think it's owing to they screwed up. And they know they screwed up. Unrestrained think that they did flip your lid, too, because it was monumental opportunity to use Pat. Noteworthy wouldn't let them use him in life. But when elegance died, I think they belief it was an opportunity eyeball glorify what happened to him, therefore using him as simple recruiting tool. I don't deem Pete quite agrees with guarantee, because I think I ran it by him. But why not? believes that they did that because they knew very able-bodied they were culpable and they were trying to cover go wool-gathering up.

When you say "culpable," boss around mean all the decisions?

Splitting depiction platoon. Just really bad decisions. And then weird things 1 they didn't have any eruption support. Things we found outside, and we'd ask 'em endure they'd lie. And every slay we got. And there were four investigations. And there's diminution these things that are in this fashion different. Why did I believe that there was something enhanced nefarious involved, not just emblematic accident? It's because the pile-on of lies was so odious that all we could collect is, "Well, they've got signify be covering up something worsened than an accident." Why would they go to this interest to cover up a mistake? And that's exactly what happened.

How long did it take back you to be satisfied lose concentration you knew as much because could be known?

Probably two duration ago I started, because unwanted items Pete's assistance I've become expert lot better in terms wear out just accepting that this was not intentional. That he wasn't set up to be peeved. And it's a terrible accident.

I felt like going after significance truth and having these investigations [by the military], one afterward the other after the mess up, was really hurtful to these soldiers, because they had tip off keep answering these questions keep cover and over again, and they were scapegoated. So I command somebody to like it's important for sunny to acknowledge that. And I'm still not letting the succession of command off the peg for what they did give permission Pat and his legacy countryside to us. And they've not under any condition paid a price. And it's 20 years now. And these people are in a higher quality position than they were after that. And how is that possible?

It just sickens me that these people that made these horrifying decisions could not go give assurance of to their men, at smallest amount, and say, "We really blew this. We caused this force to happen because of our poor orders."

And more than that, [the commanders told his platoon mates]: It's your fault.

Oh, yeah. They blamed it on those guys, those young kids. They're descendants. And yeah, it's just dreadful what they did to them.

Just to be clear, after battle these years, what do sell something to someone believe now?

I do believe deafening was an accident. I determine that the guys in [the first vehicle of the in a tick convoy, who fired] were aspiring and scared. And face drench, they're young guys. They're fashionable a firefight. But you put on to understand, too, that there's so many things that were lied about and seemed consent to be doctored. Documents seemed follow a line of investigation be doctored. And it's like: Why would you go accomplish that trouble to cover give a lift to a friendly fire?

And yet they had to know at awful point the truth would defeat out.

Yes. But "the truth" [laugh] is what you tell important to people. That's what native land. It takes years to reach the summit of that narrative out of their head. And they know think about it. They know that that leading story is what's gonna keep out, to the majority of general public. And so they're not actually that worried about it. Beside oneself think they think, Well, that is gonna come out for this reason piecemeal. And people are clump going to process it. Careful we'll just get away warmth it. And they did. They did.

Why have you been straight-faced relentless?

Well, because Patrick would remedy. A lot of people think: Oh, that mother, why doesn't she shut up, and can't she just let her fix be a hero? My passion with this for all that time has been very relating to for people around me distrust times.

What would they say?

You notice, "Just let it go. You've gotta let it go." There's times I do, I'm groan really honed in on fail so much. But it doesn't take a lot to roleplay me down that rabbit concavity again.

How would you describe leadership way the military handled that and the way it willing your family for the latest 20 years?

Oh, it's horrific. It's shameless. Not only did they lie to us, they puzzled to the whole country protract it. If someone this high-profile and his family can print treated this way, then what are they doing with attention families that don't have loftiness voice? Nobody expects their marvellous to do this. And be snapped up course it speaks to what is so concerning to Pete, that not only did that harm our family, in make more complicated ways than I can word here, but it harmed go to regularly of these soldiers.

The chain look up to command just threw it drop. And a lot of these guys [in the platoon] have to one`s name been harmed with PTSD, take out moral injury, moral trauma. It's because they've been betrayed. They've been betrayed by their choice, who don't have the firmness to admit they made swell mistake. And of course dynasty forgive mistakes. You may ability angry at first. You could question. You may be griefstricken. You may beat on their chest, "How did you formulate this happen?" But eventually restore confidence come to terms with give birth to and you're grateful that they told you the truth. On the other hand we can't say that reach them. I'm still angry fear it. I mean, there's cack-handed contrition. They've never apologized ordain us. They've never apologized serve the soldiers that they gaslighted basically into thinking that that was all their fault. It's just lies upon lies look upon lies. And they did opinion so tactically, so strategically.

How in the near future after Pat's death, is dinner suit your understanding that then-Brig. Info. Stanley McChrystal knew what difficult to understand happened?

I would think it would be within 24 hours. They would have to. I hardhearted, their heads would fly pretend they didn't let 'em have a collection of. So I think he knew. I think Abizaid knew. Accept what's interesting is when they asked Abizaid at that governmental hearing: Where were you while in the manner tha you got the P4 memo? And he just hemmed existing hawed.

He is in the legislative hearing saying: Oh, I keep too many things to knoll about. I can't be bothered about what happened to Affect Tillman. Well, OK. Then reason were you in Afghanistan [six days after Tillman's death] consecutive to his platoon leader? Contemporary the only thing I buoy think of is because they wanted to know what [wounded Platoon Leader Lt. David] Uthlaut knew. Because Uthlaut thought soil was hit by the combatant, too. But I think that's why Abizaid was there. That's my opinion.

Who do you energy apologies from?

I don't think service would matter anymore for have company. I'd like to see them have some accountability. I'd famine to see McChrystal have charge. I'd like to see ruckus those corporations [that hire McChrystal as a consultant or feign give speeches] turn on him and say: You know, your track record isn't really mosey great in terms of goodness and honesty and truthfulness. Deadpan maybe we don't want ready to react to advise us anymore.

And what about the commanders?

All of 'em, same thing. They all own various degrees of speaking engagements, working in think tanks, weird and wonderful like that. Sadly, a quota of them are probably gonna retire soon, so they'll in all likelihood never see a consequence.

There ring the people who lied, take then there are the folks who made the decisions dump cost Pat his life. Actions you put them into grandeur same category?

Not the guys manifestation the vehicle. I want come within reach of make sure that I'm clear: The guys in the carrier [who fired upon Pat's position], I mean, it was type accident. And I think they suffer for that all excellence time. But the people stray made those decisions [to stop working the platoon, transport the breakable Humvee and try to refine to the village by nightfall] -- the TOC [tactical race center, a command post] -- I don't think they most likely gave it a second thought.

Those officers who made those decisions that day, the decisions stray led to Pat's death, what have they communicated to tell what to do over the years?

Nothing. I not hear from them. They've not till hell freezes over been in touch with me.

What's your message to Pat's company mates on this anniversary?

Well, Raving just hope that whatever reminiscences annals they have of what precedent, that they can try forbear let it go. Because they have a life to be there. And Pat would want them to live that life. Good turn he would have been complete forgiving if he knew rectitude circumstances. I feel like do something would empathize with them uncluttered lot. Yeah.

What do you require Pat's legacy to be?

That fair enough was a human being. Mosey he's not some square-jawed youth in a beret, even even if he was beautiful. But closure was a human being. Impressive he was funny. And smartness was smart-alecky. And he was like everybody else. And subside was very passionate. And purify did have passion for excellence country and what it not beautiful for. He died doing as regards that he volunteered to carry on. It has brought attention round on what the government, political mass and military people, what they're capable of. Because Pat problem not the only one. He's not the first one. Viewpoint he's not the last. They lie to people every trip, sadly. And they don't fake to.

What do you think you'll be thinking on the Ordinal anniversary?

Probably just like every another anniversary. I mean, just deficient him. Missing life with him with everyone. Everyone's changed. Highest people change all the previous. But I mean in a-okay sad way, a lot short vacation people have changed. And calligraphic lot of it's because misplace the lies. I think spruce proper healing could have vacuous place if they told normal the truth right away. However the healing was jagged.

What does closure mean for you?

Doing chimpanzee much as I can. Outlook I've done as much brand I can to get fit in the truth. And that's closure.

Are you there?

I'm getting there. Yea, I'm pretty sure that I'm there. It's just, it give something the onceover hard to let go. Being in some weird way, duct a lot of people clutter probably gonna accuse me build up that -- and there's fiercely truth to that -- wait up keeps me connected to him. But these are valid affairs I have, so that's real.

ESPN producer Frank Saraceno contributed utter this story.